Sunset city skyline with tall buildings and a river reflecting the sky and buildings.

Ohio Insurance Savings, Made Simple.

We are an independent insurance agency, which means we partner with multiple top-rated companies to offer you quick and easy online quotes.

Based in Westerville, we proudly serve clients throughout the state of Ohio. At Consolidated Insurance Group, every client is supported by a dedicated team committed to efficiently addressing your needs and providing personalized service.

Award badge with a blue shield shape, displaying "Big 'I' Best Practices Agency 2020" with a blue ribbon at the bottom.
Award badge for 'Big 'I' Best Practices Agency' from 2019 featuring a dark blue shield with a blue ribbon displaying the year.
Badge for 2022 Big 'I' Best Practices Agency recognition.
Badge with a blue shield shape reading 'Big "I" Best Practices Agency 2021' and a blue ribbon banner at the bottom.
Award badge for best practices agency 2023 with a blue ribbon and shield design.
Personal Insurance Quote
Business Insurance Quote
Blue badge with star accents recognizing the agency as one of the 'Big 1' best practices agencies of 2024.

About
Our Agency

Consolidated Insurance Group is an Independent Insurance Agency representing many different companies for your insurance needs. As independent insurance agents, you have the ability to choose the best carrier for your insurance needs. That is the main advantage to using an independent insurance agency, we work to satisfy your needs.  Our goal is to educate and service the Westerville Ohio communities and throughout the state of Ohio. Through our independence, we strive to educate the community on the best options for their insurance needs. We can provide an assessment of your insurance needs with a choice of which package fits you best.

Learn more
A building with large glass windows and beige columns, decorated with small American flags, with a concrete walkway leading to the entrance.

Personalized coverage. Expert guidance.

A large, multi-story house with beige siding, black shutters, and a brick garage. There is an American flag decoration above the garage door, and a white Honda car parked in the driveway. The house is surrounded by trees with autumn foliage and has a streetlamp on the right side.

Personal Insurance

We offer comprehensive insurance solutions for personal vehicles and homeowners. Whether you're protecting your car or your home, our policies cover you against accidents, theft, property damage, and more. With customizable options like liability coverage, collision protection, and tailored plans to fit your lifestyle, we make it easy to stay protected, on the road and at home.

Learn More
Modern open-plan office with desks, chairs, and large windows; three people working on laptops at a central table; ceiling with reflective panels and electronic displays.

We offer Business Owners Policy (BOP) coverage to small and mid-sized businesses in Westerville and throughout Ohio. A BOP bundles key coverages, such as general liability, property insurance, and business interruption, into one comprehensive policy. We work with you to customize it, ensuring it addresses the unique risks and needs of your industry, so you can focus on running your business with peace of mind.

Business Insurance

Learn More
A person wearing a Costa cap and a dark T-shirt with a graphic print is using a yellow angle grinder to cut a metal pipe, creating sparks in a workshop or metalworking environment.

We offer specialized manufacturing insurance designed to protect your business from the unique risks of the industry. From equipment breakdowns and property damage to product liability and business interruptions, our coverage helps safeguard your operations at every stage. With policies tailored to your specific manufacturing needs, we’re here to help keep your production running smoothly.

Manufacturing Insurance

Learn More
A yellow front loader construction vehicle moving dirt at a construction site on a cloudy day.

We specialize in contractor insurance, including general liability, builder’s risk, commercial auto, and equipment coverage. With years of experience in Ohio’s construction industry, we simplify the process and help you find the right protection at the right price that fit the needs or your business. We have the licensed agents that listen to your risks and develop insurance solutions to fit your industries needs.

Construction Insurance

Learn More